Right now, I am working through an enormous purge of my scrapbooking supplies.
my very messy writing desk that I want to clear off entirely. I want to find a good home for the paper sorter, as it is a functional piece, I just don't need it anymore!
This is partly because I just really have too much stuff that I’m never going to use, but it is mostly because I want to streamline my process. I want to spend less time scrapbooking (so I can spend more time writing) and so I want to use my time more wisely. For me, “wisely” means less time on complicated techniques and more time on getting stories down. So I’m in the process of getting rid of lots of stamps, punches, and any left-over decorative scissors lurking in the backs of drawers.
I also need to reorganize my bookshelves. And put about 200 layouts into albums.
Plus, I want to be truer to my own aesthetic. One of my old scrapbooking friends, a long time ago, told me that she thought I had an Edwardian style, which is the opposite of Victorian: clean lines, simple patterns, and not a lot of embellishment. Sort of a modern neoclassic. I still think she was brilliant in her assessment because that is exactly my style (except for my tendency to love paisley and swirls, intricate script fonts and abstract but textural swashes of watercolor), but it isn’t always what is on trend in the scrapbooking world. Still, staying true to my style means I’ve gotten rid of anything superfluously cute or decorative.
Throughout this process, I’ve been thinking about scrapbooking in broad, sweeping terms. What value does it hold for me? Why have I continued scrapbooking after (literally) all of the friends I started doing it with have stopped? Will the effort I have put into it be something that is valued later, or will it just be junk someone has to deal with after I’m gone? What meaning does it have in my life? How much of my approach has been influenced by the scrapbooking industry and how much has just been me? Will my kids really care if all of their moments and stories are documented? Why am I sort of embarrassed to tell anyone that I am a scrapbooker?
Why do I scrapbook?
My most recent layout. That photo on the left isn't really so contrasty in real life.
I first discovered scrapbooking through my friend Teresa, who worked at WordPerfect with me and also did Creative Memories albums. She invited me to a party once, when I was pregnant with Haley; I looked at the catalog and both immediately felt in love with the idea and felt entirely overwhelmed. It seemed like so much stuff to buy! My sister-in-law started scrapbooking, and all of my bunco friends, and Chris, but I resisted because, gah. All that stuff! Then I had Haley, and I started taking way more pictures (with the horrible, awful, terrible camera we had then), and since I have always been a person who processes by writing, I was writing all of her stories down, and somehow I made myself be brave. I didn’t want to use Creative Memories, which seemed like it had too many rules. So I went to the scrapbook store, Pebbles in my Pocket, for a crop with my friend Chris.
And then I fell in love. Because, gah. All of that stuff! It was all so pretty and cute and colorful. I am not an artist, but I come from a line of artistic people. I can’t draw or paint or sculpt figures; even my stick figures are pathetic, even my handwriting is horrible. I never knew my grandpa, who died when my dad was a teenager, but I admired him because he had been a painter. My uncles and my dad dabbled in painting, too, and even though I was pretty awful, one of my favorite classes in high school was art. I grew up in a little town with a big art museum. I love art, but I can’t make it, yet scrapbooking feels sort-of like making art. So that was one of its draws.
Of course, the biggest appeal is the fact that on a scrapbook layout, you get to combine photos (I’ve liked taking pictures since I was on the 9th grade yearbook staff) with words. I wouldn’t be a scrapbooker if scrapbooking didn’t include journaling. (Or I would have invented journaling!) I don’t have artistic skill, but I do have skill with words, so scrapbooking gives me a place to share what I’ve written.
Plus, there is a sort of virtuous appeal to it. The preserving of memories for people down the road. It almost feels like a responsibility, to be the family story keeper.
But I think my reason for scrapbooking goes deeper than the supplies, the creativity, or even the writing.
One of my earliest and clearest memories is of looking through an old check register, dated during the months just before and just after I was born. When I was a kid, one of my favorite things was snooping around in my mom’s bedroom. I liked looking through her jewelry box, and sifting through her drawers and under her bed, mostly in search of hidden Christmas presents (she shopped all year!), but what I loved most was drawers or boxes with documents of any sort in them, because then I might find stuff from before I was born. In my memory, I sat for hours on the floor of her closet, reading every item on that checkbook register. Seeing where they’d gone and what they’d bought in the time before I existed. It was both magical and deeply satisfying. It was a primal mystery for me: had the world really existed before I did? Also a primal need: I wanted someone to tell me the things about myself I couldn’t remember.
I was 21 when my grandma Elsie died. No longer a child, but I still had (still have, in fact) that itch to know the details of what happened that I don’t know. She was a reader, Elsie. My dad and I hauled out hundreds and hundreds of books from her basement after she died, and then sorted them all into piles: keep, throw away, donate. Except for an old, dusty, leather-bound copy of Tennyson’s Collected Works, I didn’t want to keep her books—they were mostly paperback murder mysteries and westerns—but I had another motivation for sorting through them. I was certain, absolutely certain, that we would find a journal. I thought if we did, then at last I could know her, my enigmatic grandma who loved cats and calendars and books and my cousins but not, I ever knew for certain, me. I wanted to find something she’d written so I could solve the mystery, know what was previously unknowable. I couldn’t imagine (I still can’t) that a person who loves to read wouldn’t also love to write. I was sure we’d find her stories somewhere within her books. Alas, we did not. No journal. No old check register. Not a single annotation in any of those books, not even a name plate. She died, and she took her story with her, and after we’d finished sorting her books is when I really, truly grieved for her. She didn’t leave any of herself in writing and so she took her entire self with her to her grave.
This seems like one of the saddest things a person can do.
(Also, if I am honest, the most selfish.)
Somewhere between those two versions of myself—the young child hunting in closets and drawers and cupboards for evidence of stories, the young woman wanting words from her ancestors—is the reason I scrapbook. Sure: I do it for my kids. (I’m not really sure, honestly, if they need me to; I don’t know that any of them have that same curiosity.) I do it so they will have their stories. I do it because I love writing and I love taking pictures and I love how, combined in one place, they tell a more thorough narrative. I do it because, yes! All of the pretty stuff!
But really I scrapbook because I wish the people who came before me had scrapbooked.
I do it to answer whatever person in the future comes looking for the old stories. Maybe she wants to find a piece of me, her grandmother or great grandmother or her third cousin once removed. Maybe she wants to find stories about her father or great-grandfather or famous great-great uncle. I don’t know exactly, except I know she has that same primal need I had—to know the past. To know how the world really was back then. To know what happened before she existed. To connect to the people who came before, whose lives made hers even though they couldn’t imagine her specific self or how her world would be. And in a strange way, I scrapbook for that kid I used to be, too. No one passed down their stories in writing for me, even though I desperately wanted them to, but scrapbooking—documenting the life my kids and I have lived—assuages some of the sadness I have for that lack. It’s a panacea handed backwards through time, an incomplete circle, going nowhere practically, but emotionally it is an answering echo.
I scrapbook because I don’t want anyone else to feel the lack of written stories.